The health and economic costs of welfare reform: a quasi-experimental evaluation of the roll-out of Universal Credit in England

Authors

Silas Amo-Agyei, Luke Munford, Konstantinos Daras, Clare Bambra, Ben Barr, Andy Baxter, Heather Brown, Mandy Cheetam, Peter Craig, Vittal Katikireddi, Maria Marimpi, Steph Morris, Matteo Richiardi, Sophie Wickham, Matt Sutton

Publication Date

Feb 2026

Abstract

We provide new evidence on the mental health and healthcare utilisation impacts of the rollout of Universal Credit, one of the most significant welfare reforms in Europe in recent decades.Designed to simplify the benefit system and strengthen work incentives by merging six means-tested programmes into a single payment, Universal Credit also introduced features that may adversely affect mental health. Exploiting the plausibly exogenous, staggered geographical introduction of Universal Credit across England between 2013 and 2018, we implement a staggered difference-in-differences design using comprehensive small-area administrative data on clinically recorded mental health and related healthcare utilisation. We find substantial adverse effects of Universal Credit exposure: a 0.10 standard-deviation increase in clinically diagnosed depression prevalence, a 0.03 standard-deviation increase in mental health-related hospital admissions and attendances, and a 0.06 standard-deviation rise in antidepressant prescribing. In natural units,these correspond to approximately 113,742 additional cases of diagnosed depression, 29,993 extra hospital admissions and attendances, and 1.29 million additional antidepressant prescriptions annually by 2018. Results are robust across specifications, sensitivity analyses, spatial aggregation,and alternative estimators. Because outcomes are measured at the small-area level, our estimates capture population-wide effects that combine direct impacts on Universal Credit recipients with spillovers to non-recipients. Indicative valuations imply sizeable associated quality-of-life losses and direct healthcare costs of approximately £2.84 billion per year. These findings highlight that welfare reforms can generate substantial mental health externalities and underscore the importance of incorporating health and healthcare system consequences into social policy design and evaluation.

Publication type

CeMPA Working Paper Series

Series Number

CEMPA2/26

Research areas

Health and wellbeing, Tax and benefit systems

Links

https://www.microsimulation.ac.uk/publications/publication-588939/

Download paper

Cid:588939